January 18 2020
It’s always a bonus for your editors when a book pops up set in their home city. Linda, who has been banned from Lancashire for various unspecified misdemeanours, does grabby paws if she sees a book set in her adopted city of Bristol. If you ever have a spare 15 minutes, Sharon will regale you with the time she was driven to check up with West Midlands Travel’s press office, as she was so aggravated by the inaccuracies in a story set in Birmingham – particularly the point around which the murder revolved. All you need to know is that there haven’t been slam-door trains on the cross-city line since dinosaurs patrolled Selly Oak!
So Linda dived into Deadly Dance, the latest from Hilary Bonner, where a killer has preyed on a 14-year-old girl in Bristol. At first it seems an easy case for DI David Vogel and his team, but then doubts creep in. Linda says Bonner serves up an intriguing, multi-layered police procedural.
Staying with procedurals, she also liked When the Dead Come Calling by Helen Sedgwick, where the murder of a psychotherapist sends a northern village into shock and piles the pressure on its resident DI, Georgie Strachan. The book is a clever combination of psychological suspense and low-key police procedural, although Linda would like some stronger geographical clues next time around. The latest outing for William Shaw’s DS Alexandra Cupidi sees her learn that the Kentish Fens offer more than quiet and seclusion after the tumultuous Met. Kati Barr-Taylor says that Salt Lane rattles along at a strong pace, thanks to a good balance of action, introspection and dialogue.
Chris Roberts has been prowling the corridors of law on both sides of the Atlantic, starting on home turf with Once a Liar by AF Brady where successful New York lawyer Peter Caine has built a career defending some very nasty people. But it all starts to go wrong for him when he finds himself as a suspect in the murder of his ex-mistress. Chris says the whole cast come across as preoccupied with wealth and status, even when they are supposedly public benefactors, which makes it hard to engage with them as people. Chris got on better with Guilty Not Guilty by Felix Francis. He enjoyed the lively courtroom tussles as a man stands trial for the murder of his sister and says the book entertains as well as being instructive.
We’ve got a lively crop of historicals to keep you
entertained. Preservation by Jock Serong is set in 1797 with the shipwreck of a
vessel on an island in what became known as Bass Strait. A small group have to make
their way to Sydney, but the few who arrive have different tales to tell about
the journey. Chris Roberts says the book is powerful and will appeal to those
who enjoy history brought to life. Moving forward in time, Nick Rennison’s More Rivals
of Sherlock Holmes features 15 of the other detectives – police officers, PIs
and eccentric criminologists – who all had their day in the sun in popular
magazines around the time. John Cleal describes this as a fascinating look at a
vibrant and informative period in crime fiction history. John frequently gets on well with the British Library
classics and Murder in the Mill-Race by ECR Lorac was no exception. He
describes the investigation into the murder of the warden of a children’s home
as a confident, well-written story with standout characters, a wealth of detail
and some stunningly poetic descriptions. John always enjoys a touch of the
macabre and A Shadow on the Lens by Sam Hurcom, doesn’t disappoint. Forensic
photographer and investigator Thomas Bexley probes the horrifying murder of a
teenage girl in an isolated South Wales village in 1904, and plunges into a
world of claustrophobic suspicion, mass murder and the supernatural. It’s
creepy, disturbing, eerie, dark and spine-chilling in every way that a Gothic
thriller should be. Prepare to feel uneasy, but John predicts that you won’t
want to put it down.
John, who can spot a historical inaccuracy at 20 paces, also
enjoyed the return of Inspector Betty Church in MRC Kasasian’s The Room of the
Dead, despite some World War II aircraft errors. Although Kasasian hovers frequently on
the verge of slapstick, he always drags the reader back to the central
business of murder, no matter how many false leads abound. Arnold Taylor didn’t
get on quite as well with Gareth Rubin’s Liberation Square. Imagine that D-Day
had gone the other way, with the Germans victorious, instead of the Allies. In
the highly charged political climate that follows, a woman sets out to clear
the name of her husband, who’s been arrested on a murder charge. Despite the
set-up, Arnold felt that attempts to engender excitement fell rather flat.
We have two books this issue set in France. In Maigret and
the Killer by Georges Simenon, a young man with a particular interest in
recording the voices of strangers is stabbed and killed in the street during an
early spring downpour. Chris Roberts says Maigret is absolutely on his game,
judging the situation in a masterful manner and never looks like being wrong-footed.
Our second trip across the Channel whisked Kati Barr-Taylor to an idyllic villa
in the south of France, where a woman finds messages on her husband’s phone
that portend a lurking danger. Kati thought the big reveal was a bit flat, but
describes The Holiday by TM Logan as an excellent, easy and fun read. Also on
the Euro beat, Ewa Sherman enjoyed a trip to Iceland in company with Lilja
Sigurðardóttir. A woman’s prison sentence for financial crimes is coming to an
end, while her former nemesis gets drawn into helping her to pull another
international money fraud. Ewa says Cage seamlessly weaves together
drug-smuggling, financial crime and politics.
Kati Barr-Taylor had mixed luck with the domestic noir
ration this week. In Her Eyes has a woman’s life hanging in the balance for a
second time, but this time it’s not cancer killing her, it’s a bullet. Kati
says she was looking for escapism and found it in bulk in Sarah Alderson’s
knotty domestic suspense story. And she says that The Promise by Teresa Driscoll,
where secrets are set to be unburied after more than 30 years, has hints of
sharp writing, but ends up as a bland domestic noir rather than the
promised psychological thriller.
Viv Beeby says Susan Hill’s Chief Superintendent Simon
Serrailler’s long-running series could be seen as the Aga-sagas of the crime
world, but The Benefit of Hindsight, in which Lafferton police are just about coping with a series of ruthless and meticulously planned robberies,
is also well-written with the subplots neatly woven into the whole. Across the
pond, Linda Wilson enjoyed the combination of old characters and new in The
Night Fire by Michael Connelly. When a cold case lands in Harry Bosch’s lap, he
needs the help of night shift detective Renée Ballard again as the two look
into an unsolved murder from 20 years ago. Linda says it’s a clever, complex
police thriller. If you’re already a Harry Bosch fan, you certainly won’t be
disappointed and if you’re not, she’d recommend diving straight in. Don’t
mention the city of Bath to John Cleal if you want a quiet life – but he’s
always had a soft spot for Peter Lovesey’s Supt Peter Diamond series. He was
disappointed with Killing With Confetti which he says seemed over-padded and
with a rather incongruous dark plot. Whisper it quietly, but the series may
need pensioning off, says John.
Our YA queen Linda Wilson enjoyed jumping into Faye Bird’s
thriller My Secret Lies With You where Cait is determined not to enjoy the
holiday her mother has arranged – until a meeting with boy-next-door Marko
changes things, and she starts to think North Wales might not be quite as dull
as she expected. Linda guarantees you’ll be turning the pages fast in the hope
of getting to the bottom of this complex emotional story of love and loss.
Please welcome author Steph Cha to the Countdown seat this week – and we like her immediately, as she has bassets! And we’ll be gate-crashing her drinks outing, as that’s a very eclectic bunch of people there …
Don't forget to take a trip across the Pond to see what our
friends at Reviewing the Evidence think about new releases in the US, Canada and Australia.
If you’d like to be included in our fortnightly update email, drop us a line (the email address is on the site).
If you're following us on Twitter, you can find us chatting at .
Ten words to sum up your working life to date ...
Inspiration, procrastination, drive. The struggle and triumph of taming novels.
Nine things you can see from where you're sitting ...
A basset hound, another basset hound, a pile of books, a couch, a blanket, throw pillows, candles, a lighter, a glass of water.
Eight minutes to prepare a meal. What's it going to be ?
Instant ramen, with an egg cracked in if I’ve got it. Eaten with kimchi, which I always have on hand.